It’s hard not to enjoy the delightful juxtaposition of a psychopathic killer running amok through the prim and proper world of Victorian England, where appearances are everything, manners are paramount, and the horrors lurking beneath all that carefully maintained beauty are perhaps even more disturbing than anything a knife-wielding maniac could dream up. That contrast between aristocratic elegance and outright barbarism is at the heart of Victorian Psycho, a wickedly funny, wonderfully stylish, and occasionally frustrating new psychological horror / dark comedy from director Zachary Wigon.
Having really loved Wigon’s previous film, Sanctuary, this was already an intriguing prospect for me, but the casting of Maika Monroe as its murderous leading lady immediately made it one of my most anticipated films of the year. Monroe has firmly established herself as one of the greatest modern genre actresses with starring roles in The Guest, It Follows, Watcher, and Longlegs, and Victorian Psycho gives her an opportunity to deliver what her most delightfully deranged performance yet. No longer the prey and now the predator of her story, the results here are frequently spectacular, even if the film surrounding her struggles to maintain the same level of control.

Set in 19th-century England, the story (adapted by Virginia Feito based on her own novel of the same name) follows Winifred Notty (Monroe), a newly appointed governess arriving at the lavish Ensor House to care for the two children of the wealthy Pounds family, Drusilla (Wednesday star Evie Templeton) and Andrew (Hamnet star Jacobi Jupe). Winifred is a peculiar woman, to put it mildly, whose attempts at maintaining the expected social graces barely conceal the violent psychopathy bubbling beneath her carefully constructed exterior. As the autumn progresses, her presence increasingly destabilizes the household, eventually building toward a particularly bloody Christmas dinner.
Monroe is absolutely mesmerizing. Her sharp facial features lend themselves wonderfully to a terrifying, Joker-esque smile (in that looks physically painful to maintain) while her vacant, thousand-yard stare can communicate more than entire pages of dialogue. The actress contorts her face and body in ways that make Winifred seem genuinely alien at times, occasionally allowing every trace of life to drain from her expression before suddenly snapping back into something resembling humanity. She moves through the house like a zombie in the dead of night, simultaneously fragile and ferocious, with an unnerving physicality that makes even her most mundane interactions unpredictable.

Wigon matches Monroe’s extraordinary commitment with some of the most exciting and inventive camerawork of the year. Led by cinematographer Nico Aguilar (The Monkey), the film deploys dutch angles, invasive close-ups, cameras mounted to unexpected places, and shots that swing along with the movement of murder weapons. It all contributes to an aggressively stylized experience that constantly threatens to collapse into outright madness, but ends up being the film’s second strongest feature next to its lead performance.
The film is also beautifully textured, with particularly gorgeous nighttime color grading, while its increasingly unsettling sound design further immerses us in Winifred’s distorted perception of reality. It’s the kind of filmmaking that makes even the film’s less successful stretches a pleasure to watch.

Victorian Psycho is also very, very funny. The film’s heightened dialogue and absurdly self-serious characters provide plenty of opportunities for vicious satire, with the cast enthusiastically embracing the ridiculousness. Jason Isaacs chews through every scene as Mr. Pounds, aided considerably by an awesomely silly mustache, while Ms. Lamb (Thomasin McKenzie), the family’s nurse, provides an unexpectedly charming naive counterpoint to Winifred’s madness. All of McKenzie’s deliveries had me in stitches. Even the running gag of the pronunciation of Winifred’s surname as “naughty” managed to get a laugh out of me every single time.
Beneath the jokes and bloodshed, however, is a pointed examination of the misogyny, classism, and patriarchal cruelty that Victorian society so carefully concealed beneath its polished exterior - and of course, still resonates to this day. The Pounds family represents an institution built upon repression and inherited abuse, with Mr. Pounds himself perpetuating the very cycles of sexual violence that shaped his upbringing. The film is particularly interesting in how deliberately it refuses to make Winifred’s own violence consistently satisfying, even when directed toward people who might otherwise seem deserving of punishment.

Her developing relationship with Ms. Lamb, who rather astonishingly describes Winifred as “kind-hearted,” offers an unexpected glimpse of female solidarity, while Drusilla’s increasingly significant role suggests that the darkness Winifred carries may not be entirely unique to her. Unfortunately, it’s here that the film’s considerable ambitions begin to work against it.
The pacing and structure grow increasingly awkward throughout the latter half, with major developments occurring only for the narrative to seemingly shrug them off and move along. Seven separate chapter title cards do little to disguise the stop-and-start rhythm, and the eventual explanation for Winifred’s particular interest in the Pounds family feels disappointingly conventional compared to everything else happening around it. Drusilla, especially, deserved considerably more attention before becoming so crucial to the film’s final act.

The constant juggling of pitch-black comedy and genuinely disturbing subject matter doesn’t always work either. Wigon wants the film to be hilarious and horrifying, ridiculous and deeply serious, and while those competing instincts occasionally produce something extraordinary, they just as frequently undermine one another. The film never quite manages to walk its precarious tonal tightrope without some significant stumbles, but it does manage to cross it nonetheless. Still, there’s a persistent feeling that something is missing from this otherwise inspired production.
There’s so much creative energy pouring out of Victorian Psycho that it’s difficult not to admire it. Wigon’s fearless visual direction, a wicked sense of humor, and one absolutely phenomenal Maika Monroe performance make this a bloody good time for anyone.
‘Victorian Psycho’ is now playing in theaters.