‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ Keeps It Cool

‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ Keeps It Cool

- By Nicolas Delgadillo -->

Quentin Tarantino and David Fincher join forces for this serviceable sequel to Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

There’s something inherently strange about the prospect of a sequel to a Quentin Tarantino film being directed by someone other than Tarantino himself. After all, few filmmakers possess such an immediately recognizable voice (both on and off paper), and attempting to replicate that particular combination of razor-sharp dialogue, eccentric characters, cinematic nostalgia, and shocking violence seems like an invitation for disaster. Then again, when the filmmaker taking over is none other than David Fincher, and Tarantino himself is still responsible for the screenplay, the proposition becomes a fascinating creative experiment. The results are undeniably entertaining, even if The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth ultimately feels like something less than the sum of its extraordinarily talented parts.

Set in 1977, eight years after the events of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, the film reunites audiences with Brad Pitt’s titular stuntman-turned-Hollywood fixer, who has settled into a relatively comfortable existence working odd jobs, including as a projectionist at the New Beverly Cinema. Cliff seemingly enjoys a simple life, spending time with his father, Gus (Peter Weller), watching movies (his favorites star Hot Rod Harrison, played with effortless cool by Yahya Abdul-Mateen II), and generally taking things as they come. That changes when talent agent Karen Crosby (Elizabeth Debicki) approaches him with a problem involving film and television star Charlie Peters (Scott Caan), whose dealings with some particularly dangerous individuals have put his wife Toni (Carla Gugino), an old friend of Cliff’s, directly in harm’s way.

An important question surrounding this unusual sequel is whether it can stand on its own without requiring audiences to have seen its predecessor. Thankfully, the answer is a resounding yes. While familiarity with Tarantino’s original obviously enriches the experience, Fincher’s film is remarkably self-contained. There’s a recurring gag involving people asking Cliff about his old friend Rick Dalton, but it should only serve to make unfamiliar newcomers more curious about the previous film.

Pitt slips back into the role with remarkable ease, and much of the pleasure of this film comes simply from spending another couple of hours in Cliff and his friends’ company. The dialogue is fast, funny, and wonderfully unpredictable, while the supporting ensemble is populated by memorable personalities. Caan is particularly fantastic as an obnoxiously arrogant has-been, while Debicki brings a welcome eroticism to her flirtations with Cliff. With photography by Academy Award-winner Erik Messerschmidt, the camera has a near-fetishistic fascination with her exceptionally long legs, beginning with her unmistakably Tarantino-esque introduction. Call it what you will, but it’s also refreshing to see a mainstream Hollywood production allowing its characters to be genuinely, unapologetically sexy. These are supposed to be for grown-ups, after all; it’s nice to see a movie act like it.

The Verdusco brothers (played by Matt Groove and JB Tadena), meanwhile, are easily among the film’s greatest strengths. These two Filipino hitmen bring an unsettling menace that brilliantly disrupts the otherwise relaxed, wisecracking, and flirtatious atmosphere of The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth. Whenever they appear, the entire movie seems to shift gears, and the violence they inflict is genuinely upsetting. Their scenes are a brilliant counterbalance to the rest of the film.

On the opposite end, Fincher seems to have considerable fun recreating the cinematic landscape of the period, from ‘70s exploitation fare to the older black-and-white movies and television programs Cliff’s father enjoys. There’s a true, researched affection for the medium running throughout just like its predecessor, and the film’s gorgeous costumes (Trish Summerville), production design (Donald Graham Burt), and wonderfully realized vision of Los Angeles make it an absolute pleasure to inhabit.

Unfortunately, the cracks begin to show during an extravagantly effects-heavy demolition derby sequence that feels almost entirely unnecessary. The murky racing action is unconvincing, while the awkward cutting between the lackluster spectacle and Karen’s reactions are less exciting and more plain awkward. It’s a rare instance where the film’s considerable resources seem to work against it; even this amalgamation of talent can’t overcome the Netflix curse, apparently.

The climax also feels disappointingly familiar, essentially remixing the thrillingly tense finale of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood without quite recapturing its impact. It’s brilliant on its own, but when you’re forced to compare it to the similar beat of the first film, it pales in comparison. It’s an oddly unsatisfying conclusion to a journey that’s otherwise been so consistently delightful, although the fact that its nearly two-and-a-half-hour runtime flies by is impressive in itself.

More frustrating is the sense that, despite Fincher’s undeniable technical mastery, this never really feels like a David Fincher movie. Even his more unconventional projects, like the criminally underrated Mank, bear his unmistakable fingerprints. Here, the prevailing creative identity belongs overwhelmingly to Tarantino, but since he’s not actually at the helm, the result is something resembling Diet Tarantino rather than the genuine marriage of two distinct cinematic sensibilities that this should’ve been.

That’s both a compliment and a disappointment. It’s awesome watching Fincher flex such different creative muscles, and there are plenty of moments where this stacked collection of talent achieves an exhilarating flow. But the collaboration ultimately feels as though it’s holding both filmmakers back from the very best of their own artistic sensibilities.

The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth is funny, cool, occasionally thrilling, and a mostly wonderful movie. It’s a nostalgic hangout with endlessly charismatic characters, full of terrific performances, gorgeous outfits and settings, and bursts of impactful violence. It may not be nearly as essential as Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, but spending another afternoon with Cliff Booth and friends is hardly a bad way to pass the time.

‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ will be released in IMAX theaters globally for an exclusive two-week run starting November 25th, before debuting on Netflix on December 23rd.

Back to blog
1 of 3